r the ears and the mind, as
well as the tongue, we cannot fail to perceive that eagerness to listen
to slander, and an unbecoming proneness to censorious judgments are
here forbidden. It were absurd to suppose that God hates the disease of
evil-speaking in the tongue, and yet disapproves not of its malignity
in the mind. Wherefore, if the true fear and love of God dwell in us,
we must endeavour, as far as is lawful and expedient, and as far as
charity admits, neither to listen nor give utterance to bitter and
acrimonious charges, nor rashly entertain sinister suspicions. As just
interpreters of the words and the actions of other men, let us candidly
maintain the honour due to them by our judgment, our ear, and our
tongue.
Tenth Commandment.
THOU SHALT NOT COVET THY NEIGHBOUR’S HOUSE, THOU SHALT NOT COVET THY
NEIGHBOUR’S WIFE NOR HIS MAN-SERVANT, NOR HIS MAID-SERVANT, NOR HIS OX
NOR HIS ASS, NOR ANYTHING THAT IS THY NEIGHBOUR’S.
49. The purport is: Since the Lord would have the whole soul pervaded
with love, any feeling of an adverse nature must be banished from our
minds. The sum, therefore, will be, that no thought be permitted to
insinuate itself into our minds, and inhale them with a noxious
concupiscence tending to our neighbour’s loss. To this
[212]355corresponds the contrary precept, that every thing which we
conceive, deliberate, will, or design, be conjoined with the good and
advantage of our neighbour. But here it seems we are met with a great
and perplexing difficulty. For if it was correctly said above, that
under the words adultery and theft, lust and an intention to injure and
deceive are prohibited, it may seem superfluous afterwards to employ a
separate commandment to prohibit a covetous desire of our neighbour’s
goods. The difficulty will easily be removed by distinguishing between
design and covetousness.^[213]218^[214]218 See supra, chap. 2, end of
sec. 24; and Book 3 chap 3 sec. 11, 12, 13; and Book 4 chap. 15 sec.
11, 12. Design, such as we have spoken of in the previous commandments,
is a deliberate consent of the will, after passion has taken possession
of the mind. Covetousness may exist without such deliberation and
assent, when the mind is only stimulated and tickled by vain and
perverse objects. As, therefore, the Lord previously ordered that
charity should regulate our wishes, studies, and actions, so he now
orders us to regulate the thoughts of the mind in the same way, that
none of them may be depraved and distorted, so as to give the mind a
contrary bent. Having forbidden us to turn and incline our mind to
wrath, hatred, adultery, theft, and falsehood, he now forbids us to
give our thoughts the same direction.
50. Nor is such rectitude demanded without reason. For who can deny the
propriety of occupying all the powers of the mind with charity? If it
ceases to have charity for its aim, who can question that it is
diseased? How comes it that so many desires of a nature hurtful to your
brother enter your mind, but just because, disregarding him, you think
only of yourself? Were your mind wholly imbued with charity, no portion
of it would remain for the entrance of such thoughts. In so far,
therefore, as the mind is devoid of charity, it must be under the
influence of concupiscence. Some one will object that those fancies
which casually rise up in the mind, and forthwith vanish away, cannot
properly be condemned as concupiscences, which have their seat in the
heart. I answer, That the question here relates to a description of
fancies which while they present themselves to our thoughts, at the
same time impress and stimulate the mind with cupidity, since the mind
never thinks of making some choice, but the heart is excited and tends
towards it. God therefore commands a strong and ardent affection, an
affection not to be impeded by any portion, however minute, of
concupiscence. He requires a mind so admirably arranged as not to be
prompted in the slightest degree contrary to the law of love. Lest you
should imagine that this view is not supported by any grave authority,
I may mention that it was first suggested to me by
Augustine.^[215]219^[216]219 See August. Ep. 200, ad Asellicum, et
Quæstio, Lib. 88, sub fin. Quæst. 66; but especially Conscio. 8, in
[217]Ps. 118. The subject is also touched on in [218]Ps. 142 and De
Temp. Serm. 45, and Retract. Lib. 1 cap. 5, and De Continentia, cap. 8.
But although it was the intention of God to prohibit every kind of
perverse desire, he, by way of [219]356example, sets before us those
objects which are generally regarded as most attractive: thus leaving
no room for cupidity of any kind, by the interdiction of those things
in which it especially delights and loves to revel.
Such, then, is the Second Table of the Law, in which we are
sufficiently instructed in the duties which we owe to man for the sake
of God, on a consideration of whose nature the whole system of love is
founded. It were vain, therefore, to inculcate the various duties
taught in this table, without placing your instructions on the fear and
reverence to God as their proper foundation. I need not tell the
considerate reader, that those who make two precepts out of the
prohibition of covetousness, perversely split one thing into two. There
is nothing in the repetition of the words, “Thou shalt not covet.” The
“house” being first put down, its different parts are afterwards
enumerated, beginning with the “wife;” and hence it is clear, that the
whole ought to be read consecutively, as is properly done by the Jews.
The sum of the whole commandment, therefore, is, that whatever each
individual possesses remain entire and secure, not only from injury, or
the wish to injure, but also from the slightest feeling of covetousness
which can spring up in the mind.
51. It will not now be difficult to ascertain the general end
contemplated by the whole Law—viz. the fulfilment of righteousness,
that man may form his life on the model of the divine purity. For
therein God has so delineated his own character, that any one
exhibiting in action what is commanded, would in some measure exhibit a
living image of God. Wherefore Moses, when he wished to fix a summary
of the whole in the memory of the Israelites, thus addressed them, “And
now, Israel, what does the Lord thy God require of thee, but to fear
the Lord thy God, to walk in all his ways, and to love him, and to
serve the Lord thy God with all thy heart, and with all thy soul, to
keep the commandments of the Lord and his statutes which I command thee
this day for thy good?” ([220]Deut. 10:12, 13). And he ceased not to
reiterate the same thing, whenever he had occasion to mention the end
of the Law. To this the doctrine of the Law pays so much regard, that
it connects man, by holiness of life, with his God; and, as Moses
elsewhere expresses it ([221]Deut. 6:5; 11:13), and makes him cleave to
him. Moreover, this holiness of life is comprehended under the two
heads above mentioned. “Thou shalt love the Lord thy God with all thy
heart, and with all thy soul, and with all thy mind, and with all thy
strength, and thy neighbour as thyself.” First, our mind must be
completely filled with love to God, and then this love must forthwith
flow out toward our neighbour. This the Apostle shows when he says,
“The end of the commandment is charity out of a pure heart, and a good
conscience, and of faith unfeigned,” ([222]1 Tim. 1:5). You see that
conscience and faith unfeigned are placed at the head, in other words,
true piety; and that from this charity is derived. It is a mistake then
to suppose, that merely the rudiments and first principles of
righteousness are delivered in the Law, to form, as it were, a kind of
introduction to good works, and not to guide to the perfect performance
of them. For complete perfection, nothing more can be required than is
expressed in these passages of Moses and Paul. How far, pray, would he
wish to go, who is not satisfied with the instruction which directs man
to the fear of God, to spiritual worship, practical obedience; in fine,
purity of conscience, faith unfeigned, and charity? This confirms that
interpretation of the Law which searches out, and finds in its
precepts, all the duties of piety and charity. Those who merely search
for dry and meagre elements, as if it taught the will of God only by
halves, by no means understand its end, the Apostle being witness.
52. As, in giving a summary of the Law, Christ and the Apostles
sometimes omit the First Table, very many fall into the mistake of
supposing that their words apply to both tables. In Matthew, Christ
calls “judgment, mercy, and faith,” the “weightier matters of the Law.”
I think it clear, that by faith is here meant veracity towards men. But
in order to extend the words to the whole Law, some take it for piety
towards God. This is surely to no purpose. For Christ is speaking of
those works by which a man ought to approve himself as just. If we
attend to this, we will cease to wonder why, elsewhere, when asked by
the young man, “What good thing shall I do, that I may have eternal
life?” he simply answers, that he must keep the commandments, “Thou
shalt do no murder, Thou shalt not commit adultery, Thou shalt not
steal, Thou shalt not bear false witness, Honour thy father and thy
mother: and, Thou shalt love thy neighbour as thyself,” ([223]Mt.
19:16, [224]18). For the obedience of the First Table consisted almost
entirely either in the internal affection of the heart, or in
ceremonies. The affection of the heart was not visible, and hypocrites
were diligent in the observance of ceremonies; but the works of charity
were of such a nature as to be a solid attestation of righteousness.
The same thing occurs so frequently in the Prophets, that it must be
familiar to every one who has any tolerable acquaintance with
them.^[225]220^[226]220 [227]Is. 1:17; 57:6; [228]Jer. 7:5, 6;
[229]Ezek. 18:7, 8; [230]Hosea 6:6; [231]Zech. 7:9, 10. For, almost on
every occasion, when they exhort men to repentance, omitting the First
Table, they insist on faith, judgment, mercy, and equity. Nor do they,
in this way, omit the fear of God. They only require a serious proof of
it from its signs. It is well known, indeed, that when they treat of
the Law, they generally insist on the Second Table, because therein the
cultivation of righteousness and integrity is best manifested. There is
no occasion to quote passages. Every one can easily for himself
perceive the truth of my observation.
53. Is it then true, you will ask, that it is a more complete summary
of righteousness to live innocently with men, than piously towards God?
By no means; but because no man, as a matter of [232]358course,
observes charity in all respects, unless he seriously fear God, such
observance is a proof of piety also. To this we may add, that the Lord,
well knowing that none of our good deeds can reach him (as the Psalmist
declares, [233]Psalm 16:2), does not demand from us duties towards
himself, but exercises us in good works towards our neighbour. Hence
the Apostle, not without cause, makes the whole perfection of the
saints to consist in charity ([234]Eph. 3:19; [235]Col. 3:14). And in
another passage, he not improperly calls it the “fulfilling of the
law,” adding, that “he that loveth another has fulfilled the law,”
([236]Rom. 13:8). And again, “All the law is fulfilled in this: Thou
shalt love thy neighbour as thyself,” ([237]Gal. 5:14). For this is the
very thing which Christ himself teaches when he says, “All things
whatsoever ye would that men should do to you, do ye even so to them:
for this is the law and the prophets,” ([238]Mt. 7:12). It is certain
that, in the law and the prophets, faith, and whatever pertains to the
due worship of God, holds the first place, and that to this charity is
made subordinate; but our Lord means, that in the Law the observance of
justice and equity towards men is prescribed as the means which we are
to employ in testifying a pious fear of God, if we truly possess it.
54. Let us therefore hold, that our life will be framed in best
accordance with the will of God, and the requirements of his Law, when
it is, in every respect, most advantageous to our brethren. But in the
whole Law, there is not one syllable which lays down a rule as to what
man is to do or avoid for the advantage of his own carnal nature. And,
indeed, since men are naturally prone to excessive self-love, which
they always retain, how great soever their departure from the truth may
be, there was no need of a law to inflame a love already existing in
excess. Hence it is perfectly plain,^[239]221^[240]221 See Book 3
chap. 7 sec. 4. Also August. de Doctrina Christiana, Lib. 1 chap. 23 et
seq. that the observance of the Commandments consists not in the love
of ourselves, but in the love of God and our neighbour; and that he
leads the best and holiest life who as little as may be studies and
lives for himself; and that none lives worse and more unrighteously
than he who studies and lives only for himself, and seeks and thinks
only of his own. Nay, the better to express how strongly we should be
inclined to love our neighbour, the Lord has made self-love as it were
the standard, there being no feeling in our nature of greater strength
and vehemence. The force of the expression ought to be carefully
weighed. For he does not (as some sophists have stupidly dreamed)
assign the first place to self-love, and the second to charity. He
rather transfers to others the love which we naturally feel for
ourselves. Hence the Apostle declares, that charity “seeketh not her
own,” ([241]1 Cor. 13:5). Nor is the argument worth a straw, That the
thing regulated must always be inferior to the rule. The Lord did not
make self-love the rule, as if love towards others was subordinate to
it; but whereas, [242]359through natural pravity, the feeling of love
usually rests on ourselves, he shows that it ought to diffuse itself in
another direction—that we should be prepared to do good to our
neighbour with no less alacrity, ardour, and solicitude, than to
ourselves.
55. Our Saviour having shown, in the parable of the Samaritan
([243]Luke 10:36), that the term neighbour comprehends the most remote
stranger, there is no reason for limiting the precept of love to our
own connections. I deny not that the closer the relation the more
frequent our offices of kindness should be. For the condition of
humanity requires that there be more duties in common between those who
are more nearly connected by the ties of relationship, or friendship,
or neighbourhood. And this is done without any offence to God, by whose
providence we are in a manner impelled to do it. But I say that the
whole human race, without exception, are to be embraced with one
feeling of charity: that here there is no distinction of Greek or
Barbarian, worthy or unworthy, friend or foe, since all are to be
viewed not in themselves, but in God. If we turn aside from this view,
there is no wonder that we entangle ourselves in error. Wherefore, if
we would hold the true course in love, our first step must be to turn
our eyes not to man, the sight of whom might oftener produce hatred
than love, but to God, who requires that the love which we bear to him
be diffused among all mankind, so that our fundamental principle must
ever be, Let a man be what he may, he is still to be loved, because God
is loved.
56. Wherefore, nothing could be more pestilential than the ignorance or
wickedness of the Schoolmen in converting the precepts respecting
revenge and the love of enemies (precepts w